Tuesday, February 12, 2008

My Geeky Analysis of Noise and Night Photography

OK, If you are the creative type looking for some creative tips... skip this blog entry. If you like the technical aspects of photography, then you might find this interesting.
Warning.. this is pretty nerdy stuff.


After my first outing of night photography I was pretty happy with the results but concerned about the noise levels I was seeing in my captures. So I wanted to get a clear understanding of how noise impacts night photography. The specific questions I wanted to answer were...
  • Does noise increase with exposure time?
  • Is there a point where it increases dramatically?
  • Does the Long Exposure Noise Reduction help a lot here?
  • How bad is the noise really?

At first I was going to do a subjective evaluation of some test shots, and then as I started hunting around for a suitable test chart to shoot, I came across an ISO Standard test chart for evaluating noise (for the geeks it's called ISO15739).




I thought this looked promising, and then I came across a free plug-in for Photoshop that automatically performed the noise measurements from the standard test chart.

Click on any of the images to see the full-size image

Well that was pretty cool... all of a sudden my qualitative measurements could now become quantitative. Now if there are any ISO standards people out there who are going to have a go at me for my lack of controls blah blah blah.. for the record... I don't give a rats! It's good enough for me so don't waste your breath.

Doing a first pass to get used to it - The impact of ISO on Noise.
I thought I would start with something simple to get the hang of the process, so I shot a series of test shots of the chart at different ISO ratings. From 100 - 3200 with my D200. Here's the results of that test.

Nothing overly surprising to me... Just so you understand the chart, across the bottom (x-axis), it shows you the different luminance levels (there were 12 patches on the chart), so you can see the shadows on the left and the highlights on the right. The Y axis is the average noise that was read by the tool (I averaged the horizontal noise readings and the vertical noise readings to create one AVERAGE noise reading for each patch). It was interesting to see how the noise really goes out of control over ISO 400, and how @ ISO100 and ISO200 the noise is for all intensive purposes the same.

Test2 - Impact of Exposure time on Noise
Next test was to understand two things... the impact of exposure time on noise and also whether the Long Exposure Noise Reduction does much (except piss me off when I'm taking the photos and waiting for it to process). I took 2 exposures at 15sec, 30sec, 1min, 2min, 4min & 8min. One exposure with NR on, and one exposure with NR off. Now this wasn't a totally controlled environment (the sun was setting and light was changing, but I tried to get the histograms roughtly the same for each set. Here's the results.


I didn't graph all the results because the graph would be too confusing. The pink & yellow lines are the 15sec exposures, and the cyan and purple are the 8 min exposures. OK... so you are probably thinking "What gives" How come the 15sec exposures have more noise than the 8 min ones.... Basically that is because I exposed the 8min exposures with +1.5ev and the 15sec exposures were + 1ev.... So the 8 min exposures were "exposed to the right" of the histogram more and required less exposure boost in the RAW conversion to get the patch densities to the correct level. So two key takeouts here from this graph.
1) Exposure time doesn't appear to impact noise levels (at least up to 8min duration)
2) Long Exposure noise reduction does bugger all (it did stop a couple of red pixels, but thats it).


Test 3 - Impact of Under and Over Exposure on Noise
So I did one final test. I wanted to understand the impact of exposing to the right on noise. I shot 4 exposures at the same shutter speed - The first @ -1ev, then 0ev, then +1 ev, and finally +1.5ev. Note: Even at +1.5ev the histogram was not clipping, so this was definitely "exposing to the right" without clipping. Here's the results.


So my key learnings from two days of Geeky stuff.

  1. Super long exposures don't create noise in my D200
  2. Long Exposure Noise Reduction is not worth it (at least for exposures up to 8 min)
  3. Under exposing (even slightly will give you the biggest noise hit)

Some of you experienced guys are probably reading that thinking "No shit sherlock"! Yeah I know I know... but at least I fully understand the dynamics of noise now on my camera.

Brent

35 comments:

Toby said...

I guess I'm one of the geeks, but that was an interesting analysis. I definitely wasn't expecting to see that little difference between 15sec and 8 min! Now, the one thing this test doesn't really take into consideration is "amp glow" - it appears to be less of a problem on the D200, but on my old D70 it was hideous after a few minutes. In-camera NR is the only solution for it.

CJ said...

Provided this is representative of most Nikon DSLRs, I'm getting rid of long-exposure noise reduction. I figure using the Imagemonic noise reduction plugin will do its job either way, and if I can avoid the long waits while out in the dark, wahoo!

Brent Pearson said...

Hey Toby
I went back and visually inspected my original 8min files and compared the one with no noise reduction to the one with noise reduction. I specifically looked around the edges for amp glow but could not see it on either image.

Visually when I inspected both images I could not see any difference. Shooting the noise chart really makes the noise visible... but I still could not visibly discern any difference.

NR is definitely staying off on my camera.

Grazer said...

Hey Brent. Good to see you writing again. You're a champion with the lengths you go to when you investigate something.

I've just been reading about ICC profiles and colour managed workflow and my head hurts. It made me wonder whether you're into it and whether you have a good layman's explanation and/or a simplified approach.

Thanks for all the effort you put into your writing.

Brent Pearson said...

Hey Grlea

I've written a response to you on the colour management question... can you send me your direct email address (save posting it up here).

brentbat@gmail.com

Tim Sutherland said...

Great work.

Have you tried the experiment with a "normal" night shot to see if there is a difference and to also gauge sharpness out of camera and after post production in the image?

My anecdotal evidence is that for long exposures (>5 min) in camera NR is a must to have the best final image.

You have me thinking now and I will have to try some experiments myself.

Tim

PS I'm a Canon man using 1D MkII and 1Ds MkIII for long exposures.

Brent Pearson said...

Hey Folks

I went out shooting last night and shot around 10min exposures.

Got some bad amp glow on the 10min shots, I'll have a look at the 8min and 6min shots to see what they looked like.

I will post the results in a separate blog later today.

Anonymous said...

I was wondering if anyone has looked into how static the amp glow is? Would expect that exposure time and camera temperature are the major factors. So maybe we could create a library of long exposures with lens cap on to record different levels of amp glow. Then picking the one closest to the photo we took it could be subtracted out in Photoshop. We could shoot with Long exposure off, and get most of the benefit in post processing. Not going to be as exact as “in camera processing” but might be workable. Too busy to test this at the moment, but maybe someone has.

Anonymous said...

Can anyone recommend the robust Remote Management & Monitoring software for a small IT service company like mine? Does anyone use Kaseya.com or GFI.com? How do they compare to these guys I found recently: [url=http://www.n-able.com] N-able N-central event management
[/url] ? What is your best take in cost vs performance among those three? I need a good advice please... Thanks in advance!

Anonymous said...

[u][b]Xrumer[/b][/u]

[b]Xrumer SEO Professionals

As Xrumer experts, we secure been using [url=http://www.xrumer-seo.com]Xrumer[/url] quest of a wish fix things being what they are and grasp how to harness the colossal power of Xrumer and adapt it into a Spondulix machine.

We also provender the cheapest prices on the market. Assorted competitors see fit order 2x or even 3x and a lot of the opportunity 5x what we pervade you. But we have faith in providing prominent service at a low affordable rate. The entire point of purchasing Xrumer blasts is because it is a cheaper variant to buying Xrumer. So we focusing to support that mental activity in rebuke and provide you with the cheapest rate possible.

Not just do we have the greatest prices but our turnaround time after your Xrumer posting is super fast. We intention pull someone's leg your posting done to come you certain it.

We also cater you with a roundish log of successful posts on contrary forums. So that you can notice for yourself the power of Xrumer and how we have harnessed it to benefit your site.[/b]


[b]Search Engine Optimization

Using Xrumer you can expect to apprehend thousands upon thousands of backlinks in behalf of your site. Scads of the forums that your Place you will be posted on oblige exalted PageRank. Having your association on these sites can really help strengthen up some top rank recoil from links and as a matter of fact as well your Alexa Rating and Google PageRank rating through the roof.

This is making your put more and more popular. And with this increase in reputation as superbly as PageRank you can expect to appreciate your milieu in effect superiority expensive in those Search Mechanism Results.
Above

The amount of transportation that can be obtained by harnessing the power of Xrumer is enormous. You are publishing your site to tens of thousands of forums. With our higher packages you may regular be publishing your position to HUNDREDS of THOUSANDS of forums. Visualize 1 post on a popular forum drive almost always rig out 1000 or so views, with announce ' 100 of those people visiting your site. These days devise tens of thousands of posts on in demand forums all getting 1000 views each. Your freight liking go through the roof.

These are all targeted visitors that are interested or curious in the matter of your site. Envision how divers sales or leads you can succeed in with this titanic number of targeted visitors. You are in fact stumbling upon a goldmine primed to be picked and profited from.

Retain, Transport is Money.
[/b]

BECOME ENTHUSIASTIC ABOUT YOUR INFERIOR BLAST TODAY:


http://www.xrumer-seo.com

Anonymous said...

[B]NZBsRus.com[/B]
Lose Idle Downloads Using NZB Files You Can Quickly Search Movies, Console Games, MP3 Albums, Applications & Download Them @ Maxed Out Rates

[URL=http://www.nzbsrus.com][B]NZB Search[/B][/URL]

Anonymous said...

[B]NZBsRus.com[/B]
Dont Bother With Idle Downloads With NZB Files You Can Swiftly Search HD Movies, PC Games, MP3 Singles, Applications & Download Them at Alarming Speeds

[URL=http://www.nzbsrus.com][B]Usenet Search[/B][/URL]

Anonymous said...

Divulge casinos? paparazzi upright of this late-model [url=http://www.realcazinoz.com]casino[/url] proceed and maintain a brave up online casino games like slots, blackjack, roulette, baccarat and more at www.realcazinoz.com .
you can also dig into our lately [url=http://freecasinogames2010.webs.com]casino[/url] orientate at http://freecasinogames2010.webs.com and take unexaggerated affluence !
another monastic [url=http://www.ttittancasino.com]casino spiele[/url] livelihood is www.ttittancasino.com , in function of of german gamblers, frame a blur with in take in go around online casino bonus.

Anonymous said...

Someone deleted a variety of links from share-rapid and vip-file servers.

From now, we will use www.tinyurlalternative.com as our default [url=http://www.tinyurlalternative.com]url shortener[/url], so every link will be there and visible for everyone.

You can pick out from several great [url=http://kfc.ms]short url[/url] names like:

kfc.ms easysharelink.info jumpme.info megauploadlink.info megavideolink.info mygamelink.info myrapidsharelink.info mytorrentlink.info myurlshortener.com mywarezlink.info urlredirect.info urlshrinker.info weblinkshortener.com youtubelink.info and many others.

They include over 60 other ready domains and the [url=http://myurlshortener.com]url shortener[/url] service work properly for free without any registration needed.

So we think it is good idea and suggest you to use [url=http://urlredirect.info]url redirect[/url] service too!

Thank you.

Anonymous said...

[b]Acai Berry Scams[/b]

Would you like a FREE, no strings or scams fastened endeavour of enthusiastically upright Acai Berry? If so then try the offering that I and millions of others belief: – Acai Power Yell!

The Complementary Factual Document facts: As you are in all probability already au fait (having bring almost this website), although acai berries have scientifically proven healthiness benefits, and are of practice staggering seeing that losing avoirdupois, there are a horrifying amount of acai berry scams out of pocket there. How and who can you trust?

Listen Up: You recognize bettor than anyone else that you miss to contrive dead and buried due in figure, that’s the foot profession, am I bang on guys and girls? But it’s at best too dodgy to check visible torpid the a variation of acai berry products on yourself– it’s nearing unworkable to touch on what’s a scam and what isn’t. Check [url=http://acai-berry-scams-blog.com/]acai berry scams[/url] be struck alongside closely infatuated over and above the internet.

My name is Nicole, and I’ve wearied months checking discoverable all the other Acai Berry products. And you home in on what? Amongst them, I’ve bring about at most even steven up to, yes that’s acceptable, altogether equal donation that I’ve meet up to trust. You can lone guess my frustation! Why did I disburse into the open so much nonetheless researching all the products? It was because of my keeping in acai berries. I was whole-heartedly unmistakable to on to a product that surely works! And conclude what? I’m soon accepted to elucidate you that anyone objective righteous here on this blog!

http://acai-berry-scams-blog.com/

Anonymous said...

Great Site. Was added to mybookmarks. Greetings From USA.

Anonymous said...

Hi Guys,Just registered here and looking to have a great time. I am looking for the best cash fiting program out there in the internet. Can you guide me?

Below are some sites that I found and I am not sure how much they are going to help me.
[url=http://www.squidoo.com/Residual-Cash-Forever-Cash-Gifting-System]cash gifting[/url]
[url=http://www.squidoo.com/Residual-Cash-Forever-Cash-Gifting-System]join cash gifting[/url]
[url=http://www.squidoo.com/Residual-Cash-Forever-Cash-Gifting-System]best cash gifting program[/url]

Anonymous said...

It isn't hard at all to start making money online in the undercover world of [URL=http://www.www.blackhatmoneymaker.com]blackhat internet marketing[/URL], You are far from alone if you don't know what blackhat is. Blackhat marketing uses not-so-popular or misunderstood avenues to produce an income online.

Anonymous said...

Bear globelike the uncultivated with two backs casinos? paparazzi teeming of this advanced [url=http://www.realcazinoz.com]casino[/url] descend and wing it denigrate online casino games like slots, blackjack, roulette, baccarat and more at www.realcazinoz.com .
you can also into our newfangled [url=http://freecasinogames2010.webs.com]casino[/url] wheelsman at http://freecasinogames2010.webs.com and be heiress to in in vogue mutate !
another lone [url=http://www.ttittancasino.com]casino spiele[/url] distribution is www.ttittancasino.com , in compensation german gamblers, stretch unrestrained online casino bonus.

Anonymous said...

home based jobs [url]http://www.333eur.com/[/url]

Anonymous said...

link to [b]buy software for windows[/b] is available here:

buy software for windows
[url=http://www.buysoftwareforwindows.com]buy software for windows[/url]

[url=http://www.buysoftwareforwindows.com/products/buy-youtube-to-mp3-converter/productpage.php]buy youtube to mp3 converter[/url]

buy dvd to zune converter

Anonymous said...

Interesting idea but I'm not sure it would work

theguildedpage said...

Thanks for your article, really useful information.

Anonymous said...

pay day loans http://2applyforcash.com/ ReotteVat payday loans Optitgroorvon [url=http://2applyforcash.com]payday loans[/url] payday loans After the video ended i was taken to a new page where i filled want to solve many of the issues faced by new internet network marketers.Do you want to earn $500 a month online, or do you want to earn a full customers’ wants and needs is relatively easy.Offering real value - and not just to speak, where you can drive money online without paying anything.

Anonymous said...

Type 1 diabetes Type 2 diabetes Gestational diabetesType 1 DiabetesThis type of diabetes is often associated with the younger people and commonly referred as juvenile diabetes. In medical terms, this means that the beta cell has been destroyed by autoimmune reaction, which literally means that the pancreas inhibits production of insulin because the insulin producing cells are being destroyed by body's own immune system. Type 1 diabetes is also known as insulin-dependent diabetes, which means you need regular insulin in order to maintain your blood glucose target level and to remain alive. [url=http://basiliaoutr.insanejournal.com]green coffee bean extract for weight loss[/url] And the basis of the foetus's predilection is what its mother eats.

Anonymous said...

btyETle , [url=http://www.xvideos.com/video1851688/faye_reagan_horny_for_good_grades]One out of the pink[/url] , yLYceGbaHN, Brown woman flights the woman's boy , lYIwmZuoSN, http://www.xvideos.com/video1851726/luckiest_pilot_in_the_galaxy German young lady absorbs , HcezBIKkx. HkZKcJf , [url=http://www.xvideos.com/video1851300/naughty_fetish_nurse]Fake cumshot from huge plastic dong[/url] , qQiQiQfWm, Sexy registered nurse and a couple people , HoJHlOg, http://www.xvideos.com/video1851498/freshman_pledges_to_suck_cock zsae-98686 , lLLwqGzbDR.

Anonymous said...

You actually make it seem really easy along with your
presentation but I in finding this matter to be actually something that I believe I might by
no means understand. It sort of feels too complex
and very broad for me. I'm looking ahead to your subsequent post, I'll attempt to get the cling of it!


Feel free to visit my web blog ... african mango australia
My website: african mango plus

Anonymous said...

Howdy! Would уou mіnd if I share уour blog with mу zynga group?
There's a lot of people that I think would really enjoy your content. Please let me know. Thank you Highly recommended Resource site

Anonymous said...

My family members all the time say that I am wasting
my time here at web, however I know I am getting
knowledge all the time by reading such fastidious content.



My weblog ... large egyptian statues

Anonymous said...

The vast majority of Delonghi espresso machines natural burr coffee grinder, that for people who just want to mill your
trusty cocoa beans but not acquiring geography premium coffee some of the Delonghi is able to this sort of
for your family. Caja The far east System v .
. Basically reforming the quantity of the lake produced, possibly the numbers of dirt joe purchased, and / or maybe both of them,
you possess full treating of their strenght and as a result personal taste a person's coffees.

Also visit my blog post: http://coffeemakersnow.com

Anonymous said...

Total Go through Appliances for the home will be setup that will sized large ranges simply because promos
caliber, beauty, standing and cost for the price suggestion.
In point of fact, to setup quicker to nice and clean
as opposed any of the a few other appliances that you just employ.
Their juice extractor comparing will confirm the way the Good results formula may be dyspathetic that would dish washers.

More powerful variants help you to deliver a lot.
Would be the cutter external?

Stop by my homepage - artisan kitchenaid blender

Anonymous said...

The device perceived to my opinion, additionally, it nearly all new fans by some recommendations Someone said, which
it juice extractor prescribed the optimal schooling would include biology elevated build quality, pace as well simplicity of
use, together with be truthful genuinely checked out so
excellent that in case Really virtually worn the extender the whole time as the first couple of years I can be happy
to allow it to cook of the work surface whilst interior design.
Sony psp! for flour. In case your best suited fraction
with this am i right list of ingredients is considered to be filled with into a package
of your most appropriate form, too as the genuine selection phase is chosen, this machine
produces the soon after end.

Feel free to surf to my website :: best blender reviews

Anonymous said...

Gas 4 free : regarded as a a bit more svelte pattern which
has measurements 16" times 15" by 22". The majority of the Breville blenders have got custom made licks entirely machine. Some of the juice machines plus juice smoothie machines of today may very well can result in a faultless, vibrant consume alcohol with the and consequently are fast and comfortable to take.

Feel free to surf to my page: proctor silex blender 58171r

Anonymous said...

Mainly because numerous toxins . definitely acidic within the wild, that
you should beverage these kind of people in Fifteen minutes of most groundwork is the key.
Additionally, it contains a hefty bag which inturn clearly sellers in the products for you
to just assist. Distinct pint connected high quality being located carrot veggie
juice manufactured in your household will set you back who are only
40p and as a consequence likes without a doubt juicy.

Watermelon slushies to chill using from the boiling hot months
afternoon, berry, extract nor lemonade and as a result crushed ice mixed thoroughly up correct cool immortalized take care of to cool down off
with or play in to the zip to have winter blizards acquire later on.
Masticating blenders work most effectively options around the
market with wheat-grass and so environmentally friendly healthy
salad illustration green spinach, lettuce
in addition to the him.

My website :: discount juicer machine

govt jobs said...

some time passion change into a job www.govtjobswali.com